A tooth is worth a root canal when its root is sound and enough solid tooth stands above the gum for a crown to hold. It is better removed when the root is cracked, when the bone around it has gone, or when so little tooth is left that a crown would have nothing to grip. Pain does not settle the question of root canal or extraction, because both end the pain. The structure of the tooth settles it, and most of that can be read from an X-ray before you travel.

What is examined Points towards saving the tooth Points towards removing it
Tooth above the gum A band of solid tooth all the way round Broken off at or below gum level
Cracks A crack that stays in the visible part of the tooth A crack running down the root
Bone around the root Firm bone, perhaps a small shadow at the tip Bone lost along the length of the root, a tooth that moves
Earlier root filling Never treated, or treated once with a canal that was missed Already redone, or a wide post in a thin root
Position in the mouth A front tooth, a canine, a tooth holding up a bridge A wisdom tooth, or a tooth with nothing to bite against

Send us a panoramic X-ray and a photograph of the tooth. You get back a written plan that says whether the tooth looks worth keeping and gives the price of both paths, so you can compare them on paper.

What decides whether a tooth can be saved?

Five findings, and they are weighed together, not one at a time.

The first is how much sound tooth remains above the gum. A crown is not glued onto a stump; it grips a band of solid tooth around the whole circumference. When decay or a break has taken the tooth down to gum level on one side, the crown has nothing to hold there, and no post inside the root makes up for it.

The second is a crack. A crack limited to the chewing surface can be held together by a crown. A crack that travels down the root cannot be sealed, bacteria follow it into the bone, and the tooth is lost however carefully the canals are cleaned. This is the one finding that ends the discussion by itself.

The third is the bone. A small dark area at the root tip is the mark of infection inside the tooth and usually heals once the canals are cleaned. Bone lost along the side of the root, from long-standing gum disease or an old fracture, is a different picture: the tooth may be clean inside and still have too little support to be worth crowning.

The fourth is history. A tooth being treated for the first time has the most favourable outlook. A tooth whose old root filling has failed can often be treated again, but the outcome is harder to predict, and every reopening leaves a little less tooth to work with.

The fifth is position. A canine or a front tooth is worth more effort because of what it does for the bite and the smile, and so is a tooth that anchors an existing bridge. A wisdom tooth is almost never worth a root canal. A last molar with no tooth opposite it does no work, and removing it without replacing it can be the sensible plan.

What happens at each appointment is described on the root canal treatment page. This post is about choosing between the paths.

Root canal or extraction: what does each path cost?

Path What it includes Price in euro
Keep the tooth Root canal and zirconia crown 200–350
Remove it, replace with an implant Implant with zirconia crown, after the extraction 450–650
Remove it, replace with a bridge 3-unit bridge carried by the two neighbouring teeth 400–600
Remove a wisdom tooth, no replacement Wisdom tooth extraction 100–200

Two notes on that table. The implant figure covers the implant and its crown; the extraction that comes before it, and any graft material the socket needs, are separate lines on your written plan, itemised before you travel. And the bridge looks close in price to keeping the tooth, but part of its cost is paid by the two healthy teeth that are cut down to carry it, a trade we weigh up in implant or bridge.

If you are comparing with prices at home, a single implant in the UK typically costs £2,000–2,500 and a zirconia crown £400–800. The distance between saving a tooth and replacing it is wide in both countries, and that is the point: wherever you are treated, keeping a tooth that can be kept is the cheaper path by a clear margin.

How long does each path take?

Keeping the tooth is one short stay. The canals are cleaned and sealed, the zirconia crown is made and fitted before you fly home, and your written plan states the days.

Replacing it with an implant is two visits of 2–3 days each, 3–6 months apart: the first for the extraction and the implant, where the socket allows both together, and the second for the crown. When the socket is infected or a wall of bone is missing, the implant waits until the site has healed, which adds a stage. Which sockets can take an implant at once is the subject of implant on the same day as the extraction, and what the finished tooth involves is on the single tooth implant page.

Time matters for more than the calendar. A root canal and crown close the problem inside one trip. The implant path leaves a gap for some months, which is a small matter for a back tooth and a real consideration at the front of the mouth.

Why is the cheaper path today not always the cheaper path over ten years?

Because the two paths fail in different ways, and what follows a failure is not the same.

Take the case where the cheaper path wins twice. A tooth with a sound root and a good band of tooth above the gum is treated, crowned and looked after. Ten years on, the likely cost has been the original 200–350 euro and perhaps nothing more. The implant path for the same tooth would have cost more on day one, taken months longer, and would still need its own cleaning and check-ups. An implant is a replacement, not an upgrade.

Then there is the case where the cheaper path costs more. A tooth with a hairline crack in the root, or with almost nothing left above the gum, is given a root canal and a crown because that is the lower figure. Two or three years later it splits. You have paid for the root canal and the crown, and you then pay for the extraction and the implant with its crown as well. In the meantime the infection around the failing root may have taken bone with it, so the implant site needs a graft it would not have needed at the start. The saving on day one has become the dearest route of all.

There is a third case, the cheapest on the day: take the tooth out and do nothing. For a wisdom tooth, that is the end of it. For a working tooth, the neighbours tip into the space, the tooth above or below drifts into it, and the bone thins where the root used to be. The bill arrives later and it is larger.

So the ten-year question is really how likely the tooth is to last, and that is what the five findings measure. Where they are favourable, save it. Where two or three are against it, the lower price is not the saving it looks.

If you have been told a tooth must come out and you would like that checked, send the X-ray on WhatsApp at +355 69 691 1118. Our dentists will tell you whether they see a tooth worth saving, and what they would want to look at before deciding.

What if nobody can tell until the tooth is opened?

It happens, and you should know it in advance. A crack in a root is often too fine to show on a panoramic X-ray. A CBCT, the 3D scan used for planning, shows more, and sometimes the only certain answer comes when the old filling is removed and the inside of the tooth is seen directly.

The way to protect yourself is simple. Ask for a plan that names the doubt and prices both outcomes: the root canal and crown if the root proves sound, the extraction and the replacement if it does not. Then nothing is decided for you in the chair, and nothing is charged that you have not already read. If two opinions you have been given at home disagree, it is usually because they rest on different images, and a second opinion on your quote is a reasonable step before either path. If the tooth does have to go, the extraction page explains what a simple removal and a surgical one involve.

FAQ

The tooth has stopped hurting. Can I leave it alone?

No, and this is the most common way a saveable tooth becomes an extraction. Pain often stops because the nerve inside the tooth has died, not because the problem has gone. The infection carries on quietly at the root tip, the shadow on the X-ray grows, and the bone it removes is bone that either path needs: a root canal heals more readily around a small lesion than a large one, and an implant needs that bone to stand in. A tooth that hurt badly and then went silent deserves an X-ray soon, not a sigh of relief.

I have been given two different opinions on the same tooth. Which is right?

Possibly both, on the information each was based on. One may rest on a small film of the tooth and the other on a panoramic image; one may weigh the remaining tooth more heavily, the other the cost to you. Ask the same three questions of each: how much sound tooth is left above the gum, is there any sign of a crack in the root, and what does the bone look like. If the answers match, the recommendation will too. If they do not, send us both opinions with the X-ray and we will say which finding we would want to confirm first.

Is a root-treated tooth a dead tooth that will cause trouble later?

It has no nerve, but it is not dead in the sense people fear. The root is still held in living bone by a living ligament, it still feels pressure when you bite, and it still keeps the bone around it in use. What changes is the strength of the tooth itself: without its pulp, and with an access hole through the biting surface, it is more brittle, which is exactly why the crown is part of the treatment. A root-treated tooth that is well sealed and crowned commonly serves for many years, and it should be looked at on an X-ray from time to time like any other.

Can I have the root canal at home and the crown in Tirana?

Yes, and for a tooth that hurts it is often the sensible order. Do not wait weeks for a flight with an infected tooth: have the canals treated where you live and ask for a copy of the X-ray taken after sealing. A zirconia crown here is 150–250 euro, against a typical £400–800 in the UK. For one crown alone the journey rarely makes sense once flights are counted, and we will say so. It does make sense when the crown is one item in a longer plan and the visit was happening anyway.

Should I just have the tooth out and leave the gap?

Sometimes that is a sound decision, and sometimes it is the dearest choice in slow motion. It is reasonable for a wisdom tooth, and for a last molar with no partner to bite against. It is a poor choice for a first molar, a premolar or any tooth at the front, because the teeth around a gap do not stay where they are and the bone beneath it shrinks without a root to load it. If the budget does not stretch to a replacement this year, say so when you write: the written plan can then set out the extraction first and the replacement as a later stage.

Use the quote form to send your X-ray, a photograph of the tooth and a note of any earlier treatment it has had. Our dentists read it and you receive a written treatment plan with detailed pricing within 24 hours: whether the tooth is worth saving, the price of each path and the visits each one needs, with no obligation.